Every sword, bow, arrow and bolt with both published stat columns side by side — because the two biggest wikis disagree about the same weapon and neither says why.
Every attack value here is two claims, not one. Fextralife and Game8 publish different figures for the same sword — 51 against 27 for Hazebringer, and the same split right across the set. Our read is that one column is fully enhanced and the other is base, but neither site says so, so both are printed with their source named. Nothing in this catalogue has been read off the game client.
Fextralife wiki — Weapons index and per-weapon pages — Competitor claim, read 2026-08-05 across all 32 weapon pages it publishes. Evidence that Fextralife states a particular number for each weapon, not that the number is right — and its own prose gives the reason to be careful: every sword page says "the full melee attack damage of", and every sword reads 51 or 45. Our read is that these are fully-enhanced values; Fextralife never says which enhancement level any figure describes. It has no page for Shark Cutter, First Moon, Silverlight or Big Dipper.
Gamer Guru — All 21 Sword Locations (Blade Collector Trophy Guide) — Hands-on, uploaded 2026-08-04 — the strongest roster evidence anyone has published. The creator numbers the swords 1 to 21 in his own chapter titles while completing Blade Collector, so the count and the spellings come from a person reading the collection screen rather than from speech-to-text. It sits here rather than in creatorSources because the video has no caption track at all: the capture in data/transcripts/gamerguru-sword-locations.md is the chapter list, not a transcript. It carries no stats and no effects — use it for the roster and the locations only.
Game8 — List of Weapons — Competitor claim, read 2026-08-05. Evidence that Game8 states a second, lower set of figures for the same weapons — every sword reads 27 or 21, and every passive is weaker than Fextralife's by the same direction and rough proportion. Our read is that this is the base, unenhanced column; Game8 does not say so either. Its sword table lists 20, omitting Mechblade (Heavy) and Bell Sword and adding Big Dipper, which the Blade Collector run does not contain. Its table carries no icons.